Sushil Kumar's Blog

straight from my heart and soul

Silent Slaves from India

Kerala and Mangalore are two places in South India which caters to domestic and international demand of nurses in hospitals. Nurses from these places could be easily found in every small town hospitals and dispensaries working on meagre income and few of them work religiously for missionary work. In India there is so much uproar in media on tragic death of Jacintha Saldanha, 46, the nurse from Mangalore in the King Edward VII hospital, who was duped by the Radio Jockey, Mel Greig and Michael Christian of Australia in a prank call and subsequent humiliations. Mel Greig and Michael Christian obtained information about the Duchess of Cambridge’s health by pretending to be Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Charles while playing a prank call to the King Edward VII’s Hospital Sister Agnes, where the Duchess was being treated for acute morning sickness. In few responses to coverage of Indian media of Jacintha Saldanha case, one Britisher has said that the victim was from a third world country. It is like rubbing salt to the wound.

And India is also not a safe heaven for nurses; they are exploited financially, made to work like slaves, and sexually exploited in hospital by staff. There are numerous cases where nurses are raped by ward boys of hospital in night shifts. Cases like Aruna Shanbaug really raise apprehensions – if there is any God who took no interest in His lesser children, who turned to irreversible vegetable state from 39 years because of brain injury and spinal cord injury which she got during sodomy by a ward boy of hospital, confined to bed and suffering from no faults of her own.

Image credit:

Image credit:

I am not writing this post just for the sake of writing some another post but I knew from the core of my heart that these nurses are one of the most vulnerable and weaker section of society who are denied their fundamental, constitutional right to work in a dignified working condition, to form a trade union or to raise their voice of protests. When they are in hospital uniform, they are respected as sister but when they live in their shanties they are ridiculed in a derogatory manner.

I have my first hand, mixed experiences of witnessing exploitations and utter disregard to nurses in Delhi. I lived for six years in a locality where nurses reside in thousands of numbers because of proximity to hospitals like Holy Family, Escorts Heart Research Centre and Apollo Hospital. In Delhi and National Capital Region, there are more than 50 prominent hospitals, both state and privately owned, and innumerable private nursing homes mushrooming in city. And none of these hospitals have a trade union of nurses. In these hospitals, nurses are underpaid and overworked, most of them working two to three shifts in a single day.

I have seen nurses sending regularly ‘money orders’ at postal offices to their family members in distant villages, 2500 km far from Delhi. These nurse bribe postman to get their registered letters else he threatens to not deliver letters. Landlords abusing and threatening them to evict their rooms. These uneducated, rustic landlords extort 2-3 times rent, they cite reason that nurses works in shifts and used to occupy a room by 6-8 nurses, a room which is just 8 feet by 10 feet may cost around Rs 12,000/- or more depending on the vicinity to nearest hospital. These landlords gets double benefit from these nurses, first by rent and second, forcing them to buy grocery items from their shop. If married these nurses have a drone-like husband who sleeps throughout the day to wake at the sunset to buy expensive whisky from hard earned money of his wife.
These nurses are exploited by VISA-mafias who show them green postures of working in gulf countries. There are numerous English speaking centres which guarantee to train in perfect English for clearing IELTS and TOEFL tests. So, these nurses run the economy of colony where they reside in clusters.
It’s hard to say why these Malyali nurses don’t intermingle with local people, may be due to lack of time, language problem or cultural differences and often these Malyali nurses are mocked as ‘Mallus’ for being a Malyali.
I have seen hundreds of Kerala nurses standing in queue attired in traditional Kerala-dresses for Christmas celebrations on the candle march prior to X-Mas. This is the day when you can see hundreds of nurses altogether or else they would be busy in hospital job.
Just one year back, Kolkata’s AMRI Hospital witnessed death of 91 patients in a fire tragedy. Two nurses from Kerala – Remya Rajappan and Vineeta PK saved lives of nine patients before their own tragic death. They were rescuing patients in the crucial hour of dead night when doctors switched off their mobiles and fled from the hospital.
Like every cloud has a silver lining, one such person to feel proud of in nurse community is Annies Kanmani Joy who became first nurse IAS officer.

Image credit:

Image credit:

If get opportunity then read the book ‘Beyond Love’ by Dominique Lapierre, you may cry by knowing how a nurse of Missionary of Charity, who was from a very humble background, was died of Rabies because of lack of a single vial of anti-rabies vaccine. Medical sciences have advanced very much and we have almost conquered cancer and have medicine for AIDS but there are certainly no medicine to combat humiliation, and the feeling to be cheated. And it’s really tragic that few insane Radio jockeys and so called comedy show anchors play prank to gullible victims who can’t face the guilt arisen from the unwanted humiliations.
© Sushil Kumar


Single Post Navigation

7 thoughts on “Silent Slaves from India

  1. “One Britisher has said that the victim was from a third world country”… why take one person so seriously?

    “… weaker section of society who are denied their fundamental, constitutional right to work in a dignified working condition” … The Constitution is organized in 291 pages in the 2003 edition and now available online. It consists of 399 Articles ordered in 22 Parts, with 19 Amendments (to Page 197). There are then 12 schedules (p. 198–59), that further clarify the Articles. Five Appendices taking up a further 31 pages (p. 260-291)… Is there anyone who has read all of it?

    Please write a summary (1,000 words) that can serve as a bedtime story? A document which can be explained succinctly and simply to those who do not know how to read? What are the 10 most important rights?

    • Supreme Court of India behaves like a nagging nanny who has envisaged the idea of right to sleep as a fundamental right but it rarely roars when the issue of rights of working women or weaker sections comes, and it gives preachy lectures for the rights of workmen in unorganized sectors. It dictates like a toothless patriarch to enforce guidelines of working women to protect them from sexual harassment at workplace in “Vishakha vs. State of Rajasthan” case, but ironically it has not implemented those guidelines to its own premises.
      Constitution of India is so idealistic that its ideals have become too hard to implement in India by the enforcement agencies.

    • The link which you provided – ‘The Constitution of India is a holy cow’ by Jhelum Chowdhury is a crap post which is derogatory in real sense and spread wrong impression of a really beautiful constitution. Indian Constitution is world’s best constitution, it has not failed, the people who have to implement the constitution have failed.


    you are doing a good job but as i feel we youth should come forward to take initiation for change

    • For bringing a positive change, we have to enlighten the weaker section of society to acquaint with their legal rights and for this purpose; I know very well that you are always eager to come forward. Thanks for reading and sparing your precious time.

  3. मैं अपने छात्र काल से इन नर्सों की काम के प्रति निष्ठा देखता रहा हूं। उनके प्रति बहुत आदर है मन में। बहुधा अस्पताल में भर्ती होता हूं और छूटने पर उनसे मिल कर धन्यवाद देना नहीं भूलता।

    • नर्सें उन शिक्षित तबके से हैं जो सरकार द्वारा उपेक्षित हैं, प्राईवेट चिकित्सा माफियाओं के द्वारा शोषित हैं और आम आदमी उनके सुख-दुःख से तटस्थ है। नर्सों के व्यस्त जीवन शैली की वजह से और उचित प्रतिनिधित्व न मिलने से वे अपने संवैधानिक अधिकारों से वंचित हैं। इस बीच आम लोगों में इतनी असहिष्णुता बढ़ गयी है कि मरीजों के तीमारदारों द्वारा डॉक्टरों और नर्सों से मार-पीट की घटनायें रोज़ बढ़ती जा रही हैं, सोचिये ज़रा मायावती की भद्दी मूर्तियों और व्यर्थ के पार्कों की जगह जनता की गाढ़ी कमाई से कितने सरकारी अस्पताल, मेडिकल कॉलेज खुल जाते। लेकिन इन नेताओं के खुद के मेडिकल कॉलेज और अस्पताल चल रहे हैं। जनता यूँ ही बेसुध रही तो हालात बद से बदतर हो जायेंगे।
      साऊथ दिल्ली के श्रीनिवासपुरी में नर्सों का सरकारी आवास क्षेत्र तो है लेकिन ये भी ऊंट के मुँह में जीरा के समान है।

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s




Stories from the Streets


The immeasurable terrors of her mind...

50 Shades of me


Something Like a Storybook

from Morgan Bradham

Journey of MsT

"His breath took me in..."

DoubleU = W


Indie Hero

Brian Marggraf, Author of Dream Brother: A Novel, Independent publishing advocate, New York City dweller

Juliacastorp's Blog

Studii de dans macabru

Chris Wormald - A Photographer's travel blog.

All images and text copyright Chris Wormald 2010

Chasing Pavements Around the World

"respond to every call that excites your spirit"


Current & Breaking News | National & World Updates

The CEMS Blog

The official blog of Chennai Event Management Services


Kaleidoscope of Indian civilization

The Indian Express

Latest News, Breaking News India, Today Headlines, Election Results 2018 Live News

%d bloggers like this: